Sarasota is well known for its sparkling Gulf waters, vibrant arts scene, and luxurious coastal living—but it’s also home to a rich collection of historic residences. From early 20th-century Mediterranean Revival estates to charming 1920s bungalows, these properties offer character and craftsmanship that are increasingly rare in today’s housing market.
At the Bruce Myer Group, we understand that owning a historic home is both a privilege and a passion project. Whether you're the proud owner of a vintage West of the Trail property, a Spanish-style gem in Indian Beach/Sapphire Shores, or a mid-century modern classic in Lido Shores, decorating your historic home thoughtfully ensures you honor its past while making it livable for the future.
Here’s how to beautifully decorate a historic Sarasota home without losing its soul.
1. Respect the Architecture
The first rule of decorating a historic home is simple: let the architecture lead the way.
Start by identifying your home's architectural style—whether it’s Mediterranean Revival, Colonial, Mid-Century Modern, or Art Deco, each has distinctive characteristics that deserve to be highlighted.
Start by identifying your home's architectural style—whether it’s Mediterranean Revival, Colonial, Mid-Century Modern, or Art Deco, each has distinctive characteristics that deserve to be highlighted.
Tips:
- Restore or replicate original moldings, trim, and window casings.
- Highlight unique features like arched doorways, terrazzo floors, coffered ceilings, or vintage fireplaces.
- Choose furnishings that complement the style without overpowering it.
In Sarasota’s historic neighborhoods, many homes feature hand-crafted details that tell a story—your job is to let those elements shine.
2. Preserve and Restore Original Materials
Original materials add authenticity, value, and character to historic homes. Whenever possible, choose restoration over replacement.
Look for ways to:
- Refinish hardwood floors instead of replacing them. Original Dade County pine, heart pine, or oak flooring is a major asset.
- Repair old windows rather than swapping them out for modern ones (and you can add energy-efficient storm panels if needed).
- Polish or reseal terrazzo flooring often found in Sarasota’s mid-century homes.
- Restore old tilework, mantels, and built-in cabinetry to their former glory.
Restoring instead of replacing maintains the integrity of your home—and appeals to future buyers who appreciate historic authenticity.
3. Mix Old and New Thoughtfully
While it’s important to respect history, your home should still feel fresh, functional, and personal. The trick is to balance vintage charm with modern comfort.
Smart blending ideas:
- Pair a sleek, contemporary sectional with a vintage Persian rug.
- Hang modern art on classic plaster walls.
- Incorporate a modern kitchen while keeping vintage-inspired finishes like subway tiles or shaker cabinetry.
- Mix antique heirlooms with streamlined modern lighting fixtures.
In Sarasota, where coastal casual meets artistic sophistication, a thoughtful mix of eras feels right at home.
4. Choose a Historically Sensitive Color Palette
Color sets the tone for any space—and it can make or break a historic home’s authenticity. Look to the era of your home for inspiration, but don’t be afraid to adapt palettes slightly to feel fresh and welcoming.
Historic color ideas for Sarasota homes:
- Mediterranean Revival homes: Warm neutrals, terracotta, olive green, and deep blue.
- Mid-century modern homes: Soft pastels, avocado greens, mustard yellows, and bold accent walls.
- 1920s bungalows and cottages: Earthy tones like sage green, soft cream, muted blue, and brick red.
Lighter, beach-friendly variations can also work beautifully, especially given Sarasota’s sunny, coastal environment.
5. Update Kitchens and Bathrooms with Care
These are the two areas where modern functionality is essential—but that doesn’t mean sacrificing historic charm.
For kitchens:
- Use vintage-inspired appliances (brands like Big Chill and SMEG offer retro styles with modern performance).
- Choose materials like butcher block, marble, or soapstone countertops.
- Opt for period-appropriate cabinetry with modern hardware for a fresh twist.
For bathrooms:
- Keep or replicate classic tilework, like hexagonal floors or subway tile walls.
- Install pedestal sinks or freestanding tubs for vintage appeal.
- Use polished nickel or brass fixtures for a timeless look.
At the Bruce Myer Group, we often advise clients looking at historic homes that showcase well-done updates in these spaces significantly boost livability and resale value.
6. Embrace Local Sarasota History
Decorating your historic home in Sarasota offers the unique opportunity to incorporate local heritage into your interiors.
Ideas to celebrate Sarasota’s history:
- Decorate with vintage Florida maps or postcards.
- Showcase art from local Sarasota artists, past and present.
- Highlight architectural salvage pieces sourced from the area.
- Pay tribute to Sarasota’s circus legacy with whimsical, vintage touches (think subtle nods, not full-on theme park).
Telling your home's story through decor adds depth and a meaningful sense of place.
7. Furnish for Comfort and Functionality
Older homes often have smaller rooms, less closet space, or quirky layouts. Choose furnishings that fit the scale and function of each space.
Tips:
- Select low-profile furniture for rooms with lower ceilings.
- Incorporate multi-functional pieces like storage benches or built-in bookcases.
- Keep pathways open and layouts airy to suit Sarasota’s casual, indoor-outdoor lifestyle.
In historic homes, it’s especially important not to over-furnish. Allow the craftsmanship and architectural details to take center stage.
8. Don't Forget Outdoor Spaces
Many Sarasota historic homes feature charming courtyards, front porches, or lanai spaces that deserve just as much attention as the interior.
Enhance these spaces with:
- Wicker or rattan furniture for a breezy, vintage vibe.
- Classic black-and-white tiled patios or brick pavers.
- Native plant landscaping like sea grapes, palms, and hibiscus.
- Subtle coastal decor—think striped umbrellas or wrought-iron café tables.
Emphasizing outdoor living aligns perfectly with Sarasota’s lifestyle—and increases your home’s overall appeal.
Work with the Bruce Myer Group for Historic Home Expertise
Decorating a historic home requires more than just good taste—it requires a thoughtful approach that balances preservation, style, and modern functionality. Whether you’re buying, selling, or restoring a piece of Sarasota’s rich architectural history, having the right team behind you makes all the difference.
At the Bruce Myer Group, we have deep experience with historic homes in the Sarasota area and can guide you through every step of the process, from finding the perfect property to connecting you with trusted restoration experts.
Ready to find your own piece of Sarasota history? Contact the Bruce Myer Group today and let’s start the journey toward a home that honors the past while embracing your future.
