Neighborhood Guide: Bird Key, Sarasota, Florida

Bird Key, Sarasota Overview

What You Need to Know About Sarasota's Hidden Gem

Bird Key, Sarasota, one of the most sought-after of neighborhoods in Sarasota, Florida, is an exceptional place to call home. If you are considering buying a home here, I welcome you. As a long-time Bird Key Realtor, I am happy to provide you with the information you need to make the best buying decision for your needs. This neighborhood guide to Bird Key is a solid starting point, and I’m confident you’ll love this beautiful, welcoming community with a true resort feel (those palm trees and waterfront views make it stunning).

I’m Bruce Myer, and I cannot wait to give you some excellent Bird Key real estate insights so you can determine if this is the ideal place for you to call home.

Bird Key, FL Neighborhood
bird key neighborhood guide

Bird Key is a 250-acre barrier island located in the heart of Sarasota Bay. The community is exclusive, with only 510 luxury homes to choose from, without any condominiums, high-rises, or busy hotels to spoil the beauty of this location. It is a treasure with its blue water, private marinas and nearby are crystal white Lido beaches, but what’s especially beneficial here is the lack of tourism. The secluded streets are lined with beautiful palm trees as owners and guests explore the area, walking and riding on golf carts over small canal bridges without the requirement of a vehicle. If you want privacy, but still want to be conveniently close to Downtown Sarasota and the surrounding region, Bird Key is a solid choice.

To provide a bit about Bird Key’s history, consider that the first home here was built in 1917 after the owner, Lindsay Davie, accidentally made her way to the island years before as she was boating with a group of friends. Its name comes from the large flocks of birds that once called this area home.

The lifestyle here is welcoming, relaxing, and filled with good people, enjoyable amenities, and time out on your boat. As real estate agents, my team and I are always here to help you get a better look into what you can expect here.

bird key, FL real estate and homes for sale

Bird Key Homes for Sale & Real Estate

Bird Key Houses for Sale & Real Estate

Neighborhood Map: Bird Key, Sarasota, Fl

Bird Key, Sarasota Real Estate Videos

History of Bird Key Video with Bruce Myer Realtor

History

Location Bird Key Video with Bruce Myer Realtor

Location

Activities on Bird Key Video with Bruce Myer Realtor

Activities

Waterfront lifestyle on Bird Key Video with Bruce Myer Realtor

Waterfront Lifestyle

Properties on Bird Key Video with Bruce Myer Realtor

Properties

Explore Bird Key, Sarasota’s Best Amenities

As you get to know Bird Key, you’ll find there’s plenty to do and see here, despite how tranquil the area is. With very little actual traffic, the area is mostly a residential destination to call home, with nearby recreation and a few amenities. Many people come for the privacy, enjoy the canals and the bayfront homes, and love the access to the deep water docks that are hard to find in other areas near the Gulf of Mexico.

As a gated community, you’ll find you have more of the luxury amenities you want without the crowds here. You can easily spend some time canoeing or kayaking. Watch the sunset over the water, take the John Ringling Causeway back to the Sarasota area, or just take in the beautiful docks and green spaces at Bird Key Park.

Healthcare in Bird Key

The following are the best in local hospitals and medical care close to the community.

Sarasota Memorial

Sarasota Memorial Hospital is a full-service emergency room and hospital with 839 beds. It offers specialized medical care, doctor’s outpatient care, and emergency medical support 24 hours a day.

Sarasota Memorial Hospital Urgent Care

Sarasota Memorial St. Armands Urgent Care Center provides care for most non-life-threatening conditions. It’s available each day of the week from 8 am to 8 pm, serving patients as young as 3 months old.

local healthcare near bird key - Sarasota Memorial Hospital
local bird key dining - columbia restaurant

Bird Key Dining: Bruce’s Choice for the Best Flavor

Crab & Fin

4.5 Star

$$$ Seafood restaurant

Crab & Fin Restaurant has a stunning view (dining on the waterfront and watching the sunset is perfect here). This is an upscale but somewhat casual location perfect for meeting friends for drinks and a good meal.

Café L Europe

4.4 Stars

$$$ European restaurant

I enjoy Café L Europe for an upscale, elegant meal, especially when there’s live music on a warm summer night. The outdoor seating is perfect just about all year long.

Columbia Restaurant

4.5 Stars

$$ Mediterranean-style menu

Columbia Restaurant, located in St. Armands Circle, is just a short walk from Lido Beach. It offers a fun, more casual setup with some great food for those who love a good drink, along with fresh seafood.

Bird Key Shopping: The Best Options Nearby for the Perfect Day Out

Whether you are looking for high-end amenities or just a great café, these shopping destinations are ideal.

St. Armands Circle

St. Armands Circle, which is at the heart of St. Armands Key, is a versatile shopping destination with dozens of restaurants, shops, and other venues to explore. It’s beautiful to walk around, too.

Tommy Bahama Store

If you love the look of coastal life, you’ll want to shop here. Located with St. Armands Circle, this clothing and casual destination has plenty to offer.

Westfield Southgate Mall

Westfield Southgate Mall is the perfect place to find everything you need for shopping, eating, and just walking around the mall. There are over 100 stores located here, along with about 20 restaurants.

Bird Key Shopping on St Armands Key Circle
Bird Key Real Estate & Homes For Sale Present Mote Marine Aquarium

Fun in Bird Key: Bird Key Recreation at Its Best

There are numerous things to do nearby, but these are some of the best local attractions and amenities.

Mote Marine Laboratory and Aquarium

If you love the outdoors and marine life, there is no better location to explore than Mote Marine Laboratory and Aquarium. This is a full aquarium with everything from sea turtles to sharks located inside and ample educational material for the whole family.

Marie Selby Botanical Gardens

Nothing is more beautiful (except maybe the ocean) than the spring blooms at Marie Selby Botanical Gardens. This botanical garden is one of the treasured destinations. Spanning 15 acres on South Palm Avenue and with the Historic Spanish Point Campus, this is quite the charming destination.

The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art

The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art is in the former home of the two people who are notedly founders of this community. The mansion, which overlooks the waterfront, was built in 1927, and within are some of the most treasured pieces of art for the region.

bird key yacht club

Bird Key Beaches: Where You’ll Want to Be

As noted, this location is on a tiny island surrounded by canals, but the waterfront is nearby. Some of the best beaches include:

Lido Beach

The largest and most sought-after beach for those visiting the area, Lido Bech is still one of the best for fun in the sand.

North Lido Beach

A bit more quaint and private, North Lido Beach provides some great opportunities for relaxing under the sun.

South Lido Beach

With about 100 acres of land surrounding it, this is an excellent choice for exploration of the area’s ecosystem, especially Big Sarasota Pass, the Sarasota Bay itself, and the Gulf of Mexico.

The Best of Bird Key Golf Courses

You are likely to spend your time on any of the championship golf courses in the area (even if you don’t love golf, the breezes make it a relaxing retreat).

Links on Longboat

A solid option on Longboat Key, this golf club is an excellent 6748-yard golf course for those who want a challenge.

Harborside Golf Course

Harbourside Golf Course is home to 3 different 18-hole golf courses. It’s noted for its sable palm trees and beautiful fairways.

bird key sarasota

Bird Key, Sarasota Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Weather and Climate in Bird Key, Sarasota, FL

There’s no doubt that this area has so much to offer, but the weather is one of the reasons many make the move. Temperatures average about 80 during the summer and drop to about 50 in the winter, with some days getting around 42 degrees. Humidity is high in most of the warmer months.

Reasons to move to Bird Key Sarasota, FL

As a local Bird Key real estate agent, I enjoy spending my time in Bird Key for the peace and quiet, but there are quite a few reasons to visit. Bird Key schools are a part of the Sarasota school system and are typically very good. You will also find numerous Bird Key parks nearby, even outside of the key itself in surrounding areas.

There’s much to do and see here, including exploring the main thoroughfare on Key Drive, taking in the luxurious presence of the wildlife, and enjoying the simple joy of this area. Most people are a member of the Bird Key Yacht Club, especially if they plan to spend some time on the water. If you are considering why to move here or to the surrounding areas like Siesta Key or Lido Key, I will tell you that the luxury presence on Bird Key is the best.

Explore luxurious homes in the island community of Bird Key. Homes in Bird Key are known for their regal architecture and expertly designed interiors, as well as the tranquility they offer residents. Secluded from the hustle and bustle of Sarasota, Bird Key is conveniently located in an environment that’s both peaceful and still close to top attractions in the area.

Many of the homes in Bird Key offer direct ocean access via boat slips or private docks. Sailing enthusiasts will revel in living so close to the ocean, and having the perfect spot to store their boats. When you live in Bird Key, almost every day presents the perfect opportunity to explore the crystal blue waters of the Atlantic Ocean or the Sarasota Bay.

Selling Your Bird Key Home?

Selling a home in Bird Key? We can help! Learn more about listing your home with Bruce Myer, including the tools and resources we offer our sellers, our marketing strategies, and our featured listings.

CONTACT BRUCE MYER

Quick Facts

County: Sarasota

Population (2000 est.): 857

Area: 9.3 square-miles

Zip Code: 34236

Shopping & Dining: St. Armands Circle 

Recreation:Bird Key Park, Myakka River State Park, Mote Marine Aquarium

Highlights of Bird Key, Sarasota

THE ATMOSPHERE

Secluded and bright, the small community of Bird Key is a tranquil escape for its residents.

THE CULTURE

Sailing enthusiasts will love living in a community whose homes feature boat ramps and slips.

THE BEACH

Enjoy living just a stone’s throw from one of the most fabulous beaches in Florida!

Bird Key Real Estate Overview: Trends And Insights

Bird Key is an exclusive island community located off the Ringling Causeway between the Downtown Sarasota mainland and Lido Key. With a rich history and 504 homes, Bird Key offers various real estate options, including multi-million dollar canal homes and vintage non-waterfront homes. The neighborhood is renowned for its gorgeous waterfront properties, making it one of the most prestigious locations in Sarasota[4]. The real estate market on Bird Key is characterized by its high demand and limited inventory, with 11 to 13 homes typically available for sale at any given time, starting at $1,950,000[1][2][3]. The neighborhood’s superb location between downtown Sarasota and Lido Beach and its proximity to the Bird Key Yacht Club, which offers social activities and fine dining, make it an attractive place to live for those who enjoy a waterfront lifestyle[4].

 

Key Demographics

Demographically, Bird Key is about 2.5 miles from Lido Beach and 5.5 miles from the Sarasota International Airport. The neighborhood is a gated community with a 24-hour attendant, and the Bird Key Yacht Club provides various amenities, including tennis, a pool, and a fitness center. However, it’s important to note that the area around the Ringling Causeway Bridge and downtown experiences higher traffic. Despite the gate attendant, the roads are public, and the neighborhood is somewhat open to pets, subject to specific pet policies[4].

 

Trends And Forecasts

Bird Key’s real estate market is influenced by its proximity to downtown Sarasota and the limited availability of waterfront properties. The neighborhood’s desirability and the exclusivity of its waterfront homes contribute to its stable and appreciating housing prices. Additionally, the impact of demographic and economic factors, such as population growth and job opportunities in the Sarasota area, plays a significant role in shaping the real estate market on Bird Key[2].

The real estate market in Bird Key, Sarasota, FL has shown significant price trends in recent times. According to Realtor.com, the median listing home price in Bird Key was $4 million in November 2023, reflecting a 13% year-over-year increase. The median listing home price per square foot was $1.2K[3]. Redfin also provides insights, indicating that the median sale price in Bird Key, FL, is $2.28 million, a 3.7% increase since last year. However, the sale price per square foot has decreased by 23.2% since last year. The average days on the market are 4.9% under the list price, reflecting the high demand for properties in the area[6].

These price trends illustrate the strong appreciation and demand for real estate in Bird Key, Sarasota, FL. The data indicates a notable increase in median listing home prices, making it essential for potential buyers, sellers, and investors to stay informed about the evolving market conditions in this exclusive island community.

Sources:
[1] downtownsarasota.com
[2] realtor.com
[3] zillow.com
[4] sarasotahomes.com
[5]chnep.wateratlas.usf.edu
[6]redfin.com

Frequently Asked Questions

Bird KEY REAL ESTATE RESOURCES

Have you been searching for the perfect oceanfront home in Sarasota or Manatee County? If so, we should chat. I have home-buying resources and local community information to assist you in finding the perfect beach home in Bird Key. If you ever have any questions about real estate here, please don’t hesitate to contact me.

Talk to Bruce
Your Dedicated Bird Key Realtor

From boaters to those looking for exceptional privacy, there’s much to learn about the limited availability of homes for sale in Bird Key. I encourage you to contact my real estate brokerage today and let my realty team go to work for you. Contact Bruce Myer Realtor now.